Spoiler Alert Possibility. If you are anything like me and can easily seek out rabbit holes to throw yourself down, be aware that there may be some spoiler alerts coming up.
To Catch a Thief if one of my favorite movies. How can you go wrong with a Hitchcock film starring Grace Kelly and Cary Grant? It’s one of my go-to movies if I wake up during the night and my brain won’t let go (I own it via my cable company). It’s also what I play in my head if I need to pass some serious time (think MRI kinds of things); the last MRI of my ankle took 45 minutes and I got almost all the way through to the final scene.
Considering how many times I seen the opening credits, I’m not sure why I just realized a few weeks ago that the movie is based on a novel of the same name by David Dodge, who wrote quite a few books back in the fifties and sixties and was quite a success, especially after Thief got picked up by Hitchcock and turned into an Academy-award winning film. Well, you know me – I had to find the book. I read online that they made quite a few changes to the book while filming and that just ignited my desire to find it. Inter-Library Loan to the rescue!
This is backwards for me. Normally if there is a movie made from a book, I try to get the book read before I see the movie. (Sometimes this backfires – having read The Martian before the movie was out, I realized that I NEVER want to see the movie. What I have in my head is all that I want.) Occasionally though I see a movie and eventually read the book. This doesn’t happen too often although a couple of times it’s caused me heartache. Both The Natural and Suspicion were movies that I really liked and had seen multiple times. Then I read the books and now can never see those movies again. It’s one thing to make changes to a book, but oh my goodness. Neither of those movies even began to keep true to the heart of the story or the characters. And this is really sad because Suspicion is another Hitchcock/Grant pairing. Just can’t do it.
Anyway, back to Thief. Having prepared myself for a book quite unlike the movie, I was pleasantly surprised. The main story lines match up closely, although the book has way more moving characters than the movie. The bad guy is the same, although the motivation of that character is different between the book and the film. The insurance guy isn’t nearly as interesting a character in the book as John Williams played. The final denouement had a similar twist but I preferred the movie version – especially since it involves a drop-dead gorgeous gold gown (designed by Edith Head). There were also a few places where dialog from the book was dropped into the movie. The main differences that I could see were some of the shifting morality/ethics in the book that were not present in the movie. In the movie, even the thief was a good guy; in the book things were much more loosey goosey. In fact, the strictly upright best friend completely flip flops in the end and decides to protect the bad guy – nobody goes to jail in the book.
I knew going into this that the book probably wasn’t going to mar my enjoyment of the movie, but it was nice that the two actually fit together better than I expected. I’ve decided that I prefer the movie – the plot line is a little cleaner and, of course, the cinematography is stunning. Guess I’m safe to keep playing it in my head when I need to!
Do you any favorite movies? Are any of them adapted from books?