My little friend next door, Minnie, loves to sing and dance. For the past two summers she had done a summer camp at the Lundstrum Performing Arts Center; this year they presented Annie Jr (just a shorter version of Annie). Considering that it is all untrained kids and that they get the whole thing together in two weeks, they did a great job.
This was all that Minnie talked about for two weeks. In addition to previewing the song/dance that she was in, she regaled me with stories of how things were progressing and who was playing what part. There were several kids who had been in Little Mermaid with her last year and although I did see the show last year, I couldn’t have told you any of the players except Minnie.
Of course there was also the post-production discussion the day after the last performance. I commented that the young man who played Rooster Hannigan did a nice job. He also had a great dance solo dressed as a street Santa in the N.Y.C. song. Minnie quickly pointed out that he had played Prince Eric in Little Mermaid. When I said I hadn’t remembered that, she commented that he hadn’t had to do very much to be the prince. Then she added, almost as an afterthought, that princes don’t usually have much to do.
In her world, all her princesses and princes are represented by Disney. As I thought about it the next few days, I realized that Disney has, for the most part, not spent too much energy on princes. Snow White’s prince doesn’t have a name, Sleeping Beauty’s prince does have a name (and a bit of backstory) but doesn’t have much personality. Cinderella’s prince is also pretty non-descript. Ariel’s prince is a little bland and definitely clueless. Belle’s prince spends most of the movie as a beast and Tiana’s prince spends most of the movie as a frog. Merida has three princes, all of whom are a bit… lacking. A few princes fare a bit better in their Disney representation but clearly it’s all about the princesses.
I’m not too worried about this unfair portrayal – I doubt that young girls and boys are too damaged by this uneven treatment. But I also don’t believe that Barbie dolls are inherently evil either.
If you were to be a Disney princess or prince (or villain if you prefer) for a week, who would you choose?
