I have a fair few number of favorite fictional characters but I know it won’t surprise anybody here that Sherlock Holmes and Hercule Poirot are tops in my book. I have the movies Hound of the Baskervilles (Basil Rathbone and Nigel Bruce) as well as Murder on the Orient Express (Albert Finney) saved on my TV so it’s accurate to say I’ve seen them repeatedly.
Several years ago my BFF and I decided that for our birthdays we would do experiences together rather than do more “stuff”. She does Cantus tickets for us and I do a play for us each fall. I pick three options, write them up a bit and she chooses one.
This year, a production called Holmes/Poirot was finally scheduled at Park Square Theatre. There had been discussion of it during the summer of 2023, but it never materialized. When I presented BFF with the three choices this year, I had my fingers crossed that she would choose Holmes/Poirot. Luckily she’s a sleuth fan as well. We’ve done a couple of other Sherlock “knock-offs”s as well as doing the Science Museum exhibition a couple of years ago.
The expectation was that the play would be a mash-up with the detectives pitted against each other, even though you’d have to mess with the time continuum to do this. Considering I’ve read a book with Sherlock as a dog and another with a time traveling Miss Marple facsimile, I can handle a little time continuum disturbance. When we sat down with our programs, it was clear that it was going to be two different stories…. Holmes in Act One and Poirot in Act Two. The two main actors change roles for the second act. Sherlock Holmes becomes Colonel Hastings and John Watson becomes Hercule Poirot. The other seven actors switch up characters as well.
During intermission BFF and I wondered aloud how long it would take us to re-orient ourselves to the actors changing parts. We didn’t need to worry. Within just a couple of minutes, we were all in. It was an inspired juxtaposition; both actors were excellent and completely believable in their roles. The second act was played for more comedy, which was perfect because…. well… Poirot. It’s hard not to play him with a splash of silliness.
Absolutely no spoiler alerts here but suffice it to say that the writing was great and had BFF and I guessing to the end of each segment. It was an immediate standing ovation. I’m highly recommending this if you can stlll get tickets.
Do you have a preferred detective? Fictional or otherwise?













